news 18 April 2017

Professional recklessness vs Reckless recklessness

Professional recklessness

Every accident has consequences. The most obvious and that every preventionist must prioritize are the damage that unwanted events can generate in the injured worker. That said, there are also a number of more legal consequences that must be taken into account. And particularly, and reason for this writing, those that emanate from the action or omission on the part of the worker himself in his workplace (business breaches that may generate an accident at work are excluded from this writing). The classification of breaches will determine the degree of responsibility of the different agents and, where appropriate, the possible infringements and compensation that may result from them. In this context, one of the main legal conflicts that arise when an accident occurs must be included: the responsibility of the worker. This discussion is key to legally clarify the repercussions it will have on the employer, the worker, Mutua, etc.

But how can the responsibility of the worker be delimited? The General Social Security Law distinguishes two types of recklessness: professional and reckless. Sometimes their identification is not easy and it is not always a peaceful matter, especially since the consequences - economic, legal, etc. - are very different depending on the type of recklessness.

The Social Security Act distinguishes between professional recklessness and recklessness. #PRLShare on X

Professional recklessness would be one where there is a causal link between work and accident. That which is a consequence of the usual performance of a job and derives from the confidence that it inspires by the repetition of the same acts (STS of 18 September 2007). In other words, an overconfidence or carelessness and a lack of perception of the risk involved in the task. But, as established by Spanish legislation, the company is legally bound by the duty of vigilance where it is necessary to include anticipating possible carelessness or excess of trust on the part of the worker.

Unlike professional recklessness, reckless recklessness breaks the causal link between the accident and the job (and therefore will not be considered an accident at work). It is, as defined by jurisprudence, as that behavior that assumes unnecessary, capricious and serious risks as well as a clear risk, exempt from the most elementary prudence required, consciously and voluntarily contravening the orders of the

employer.

It is not the objective of this writing to establish the limits of each of them, but let us use as an example some sufficiently clear situations where any nuance is ignored. In the case of the professional we can find the use of a staircase in poor condition, accessing the work through a place not enabled but generally used, doing a task too hastily, etc. With regard to reckless recklessness, we could cite cases such as going down the guardrails of the stairwell and not by the staircase itself, leaving the work through an opening of a first floor, etc.

Sergi Perez Diago
Senior Technician in Occupational Risk Prevention
INPREIN, S.L

.