news 08 October 2015

The new notarial monitoring procedure

Since last July 23, it is possible to replace said judicial payment requirement with a requirement to be practiced by any notary of the debtor's domicile, in what has been popularly known as the “notarial monitoring procedure”

Since 2001, the mechanism most used by companies for the collection of arrears in court has been the monitoring procedure. With a simple letter (without the intervention of a lawyer or power of attorney) and providing an invoice and a delivery note or any other principle of sufficient proof, the competent judicial body required payment to the debtor and, if the latter did not pay or oppose, within a period of 20 days, the corresponding enforcement proceedings against the debtor could be initiated, without further formalities.

However, it is well known that justice is anything but fast, agile and effective, and therefore this seemingly simple procedure often became a slow and ineffective procedure.

Since July 23, it is possible to replace said judicial payment requirement with a requirement to be practiced by any notary of the debtor's domicile, in what has been popularly known as the “notarial monitoring procedure”.

The main advantage of this reform is the greater speed in the processing of the procedure, as well as the express possibility of incorporating interest on delay (in the traditional monitoring procedure the majority jurisprudence denies such an option).

However, it must be borne in mind that, compared to the judicial monitoring procedure, said alternative has certain limitations or drawbacks:

1. It is not a free procedure. Although the fee to be collected by the notary has not yet been approved, the sum of the cost of the deed, which will predictably depend on the debt claimed, and that of the departure to make the notification by the notary, will make the cost too high for claims for a small amount, so it is advisable to always ask for a preliminary estimate from the Notary

.

2. Among others, debts contracted by a Public Administration, or those derived from a contract formalized by an entrepreneur or professionals with consumers and users, cannot be claimed.

3. If the debtor is a legal person, the notary must practice the payment requirement compulsorily with a member of the administrative body or with a person with sufficient powers (with the consequent greater difficulty of notification and/or possibility of obstructive actions by

the debtor).

4. In the case of several debtors, the opposition of one debtor may automatically entail that of all debtors (with the consequent obligation to go to the corresponding declaratory judicial procedure against all of them)

.

5. If the payment requirement turns out to be negative because the debtor is not located, the notary, unlike what the court does, cannot take any action to find out the debtor's domicile, and must file the proceedings

.

In summary, since July 23, 2015, the “notarial monitoring procedure” is a quick alternative for the collection of arrears, provided that we have an address where we know for sure that the debtor will be found, and that the amount of the procedure is of an amount sufficient to offset the costs of the Notary. In other cases (debts of a small amount, doubts about the domicile where to request payment, claims to consumers and users, certainty that there would be opposition, existence of several debtors, etc.), it will be more advisable to continue resorting to the traditional judicial monitoring procedure.

Finally, remember that although in the initial phase of the monitoring, both judicial and notarial, the intervention of a lawyer is not required, in both cases, the opposition will oblige to file an ordinary procedure, and the absence of a response to the request, when initiating an enforcement procedure, in which the intervention of a lawyer will always be essential.

LLOPIS DE AYSA — Lawyers
Legal and commercial advice of the Guild